When Kali came to France

Blake's Robin, Africa's unfinished freedom, and Europe's encounter with the ledger of Karma.

By Pt. Satish K Sharma, on behalf of the Dharmic Truth and Reconciliation Council - DTARC.org

On the 17th October, when Hindus around the world were revering and paying homage to Devi Mahakali, as a part of Navratri (Nine Nights of the Divine Feminine), Devi Mahakali arrived in Paris.

Not as a visitor seeking permission. Not as another exhibit to be catalogued, interpreted, and placed behind European glass. But as a question that the former imperial capitals have spent generations refusing to answer.

What happens when the consequences of empire cease to remain conveniently elsewhere?

Mahakali over Paris: an allegory of consequence, accountability, and the ending of imperial immunity.

The Paris of this image is a spiritual and political metaphor, not a report of a literal divine appearance or a particular attack. Its flames illuminate an argument: no civilisation can indefinitely export suffering while expecting to import only prosperity.

Mahakali stands here for the ending of that expectation.

Even the robin has a claim upon Heaven

William Blake understood something that the administrators of empire preferred to forget:

“A Robin Redbreast in a Cage Puts all Heaven in a Rage.”

The robin is small. Its captor may be powerful. Yet the moral universe does not measure the legitimacy of freedom by the size of the prisoner.

The ledger kept by Karma does not lose the entry. The cage is recorded. The stolen freedom is recorded. So is the arrogance of the hand that says: you are too small to matter.

If even the robin possesses a claim upon Heaven, what of Africa?

What of its right to freedom from enslavement, conquest, forced labour, and the structures of dependency that survived the lowering of colonial flags?

This is the question beneath the challenge to French influence in Africa. Decisions to end foreign military agreements and debates over monetary sovereignty are not merely diplomatic inconveniences. They raise a basic question: does independence include the right to refuse the former coloniser? [1]

France claims that right for itself. Africans are entitled to claim it too.

Full decolonization is sovereignty, not violence.

When Africa had no seat at the table

At the Berlin Conference of 1884-85, European powers helped establish the rules through which the Scramble for Africa would proceed. No African representatives were invited to decide the future of the societies whose territories and sovereignty were at stake. The conference did not draw every subsequent colonial boundary, but it formalised a framework for imperial acquisition and “effective occupation.” [2]

Africa was not empty. It contained kingdoms, political communities, cities, trading networks, intellectual traditions, and sacred geographies.

What was absent was not African civilisation. It was European recognition of African authority over African life.

That distinction matters. Empire begins by treating another people’s sovereignty as an obstacle to be removed. It then presents the removal as a contribution to civilisation.

France repeatedly denied African peoples the rights it proclaimed as universal: freedom, equality before the law, protection from torture, control over their labour, and the right to govern themselves. These were not occasional lapses. They were methods of colonial rule.

In Algeria, conquest was followed by dispossession. From the invasion of 1830 until independence in 1962, France ruled a population denied its own sovereignty. Cultivable land was confiscated to make way for settler colonisation, transferring land and its productive value from Algerians to settlers. [3] During the independence war, the French state maintained a detention system that enabled torture and disappearances. France’s presidency acknowledged that system in 2018. The torture was not made lawful by its official purpose: it was used to defend colonial power. [7]

In French West and Equatorial Africa, the state compelled Africans to work for colonial purposes. People were forced to harvest export crops, carry supplies, and build roads and railways. In French Congo, concession companies used compulsory labour to extract rubber; French authorities supplied coerced workers to private employers. Africans lost the freedom to refuse. French companies obtained labour on coercive terms, while the colonial state obtained infrastructure and export production without paying the cost of freely negotiated labour. [8] The Congo-Océan railway, built between 1921 and 1934, cost thousands of forced labourers their lives. Commercial gain and colonial control were built upon those deaths. [9]

In Madagascar, legal inequality and forced labour were enforced by violence. The colonial indigénat assigned the colonised an inferior legal status. When the 1947 uprising challenged French rule, French forces answered with torture, executions outside the courts, and massacres. France denied both the right to freedom and the right to life in order to preserve its authority. [4]

At Thiaroye, France killed men to whom it owed wages. On 1 December 1944, French troops massacred African veterans who had fought for France during the Second World War and were demanding their legitimate pay. France had accepted their military service but denied them the treatment and payment they were owed. Disagreement over the final death toll does not alter what happened: men demanding justice were met with gunfire. [5]

Haiti shows the financial logic in its starkest form. Its people defeated slavery and declared independence in 1804. In 1825, France used the threat of naval force to demand 150 million francs as the price of recognising that independence. The demand was at least ten times Haiti’s annual state revenue. It was reduced to 90 million francs in 1838, but the burden remained: the formerly enslaved republic had to compensate former colonial property owners, with enslaved people included in the valuation of their supposed losses. French banks and bondholders also benefited from the loans needed to make the payments. Haiti’s first 30-million-franc loan delivered only 24 million after bank commissions, leaving six million francs deducted before Haiti could use the money. [10]

The financial benefit was concrete: land for settlers, coerced labour and export production for companies and the colonial state, and indemnities, commissions, and interest for former colonists and financiers. These are identifiable transfers of wealth and labour, not a metaphor. They do not require an invented single figure for the net profit of the entire empire.

France proclaimed liberty while denying it to African peoples. It proclaimed equality while administering legal inferiority. It proclaimed human dignity while making African bodies and resources serve colonial wealth. The contradiction was not accidental. It was the system.

The bayonet and the balance sheet

Formal independence did not automatically dissolve the relationships through which power had operated.

The CFA franc makes the question especially visible. Created in December 1945, its original name referred explicitly to France’s African colonies. Its subsequent names changed, and its peg moved from the French franc to the euro, but its origins remain part of its institutional history. [6]

The CFA currencies still serve fourteen African countries, and Comoros has a separate French-linked currency arrangement. These are sovereign states, not territories legally governed by France. But French involvement did not end with their independence. In West Africa, the reform announced in 2019 ended compulsory reserve deposits at the French Treasury and removed French representatives from the regional central bank’s governing bodies; the euro peg and French convertibility guarantee remain. In Central Africa, France retains representation at the regional central bank. In Comoros, France appoints half the central bank’s board. The mechanisms differ, but France remains a party to the monetary arrangements. [11]

There is a documented financial benefit to the French state. Deposits held at the French Treasury reduce the amount France needs to borrow to meet its financing requirements. They are African central-bank assets, not money France owns outright, and France pays interest on them: €62.6 million in 2019. Calling the deposits an annual colonial tax would be false; denying their value as a source of French Treasury funding would also be false. [12]

The political principle needs no qualification. African peoples have the right to decide their monetary future. France has no entitlement to permanent access to their reserves, resources, or strategic cooperation. A country’s freedom is not conditional on its continuing usefulness to its former ruler.

Sovereignty establishes who is entitled to make policy and who must answer for its consequences. A former colony does not owe its former ruler permanent strategic usefulness.

If Africa could speak

At this point, the argument must cease to be a European conversation about Africa. If Africa could speak as a single voice, not erasing its many peoples and disagreements but giving expression to their claim to self-determination, this is what it might say:

People of France, people of Europe, and citizens of the world: begin with the historical record.

Do not begin with your discomfort at our refusal. Begin with the conditions that made refusal necessary.

For generations, French power entered our lands through force of arms. It was maintained through conquest, forced labour, the suppression of resistance, and the extraction of wealth. Later, the instruments included agreements, military relationships, currency arrangements, and networks of political and commercial influence.

We remember Algeria. We remember Madagascar. We remember Thiaroye. We remember the men who fought for France and then had to struggle to obtain what France owed them.

These are not decorative grievances brought out to embarrass a guest. They are part of the history through which our present circumstances were made.

Independence was not intended to be a ceremonial change of management. It was not a promise that African leaders could occupy presidential palaces so long as the most important decisions remained agreeable to Paris.

It meant the right to determine our political future.

When we question foreign bases, we are exercising that right. When we debate currencies, reserves, and monetary policy, we are exercising that right. When we review resource agreements or seek different partners, we are exercising that right.

You need not approve every decision. You must stop treating your approval as the source of its legitimacy.

Nor do we mistake a military ruler’s declaration for the whole voice of a people. African sovereignty belongs to Africans, not merely to those who command armies or occupy offices. A government cannot claim freedom from foreign domination while denying its own people accountability and political agency.

But the failures of African governments do not restore Europe’s title to rule. We therefore place before France and Europe a simple moral question.

If the violence through which colonial power was built could be justified, minimised, or forgotten, on what consistent principle is the peaceful ending of its remaining privileges treated as uniquely disturbing?

Why was domination described as order, while the refusal of domination is so readily described as disorder?

We are not asking for the freedom to punish French civilians. We are asking for the freedom to stop being governed by inherited obligations to French power.

We do not ask for apologies alone. We ask for transparent agreements, genuine monetary choice, accountable security partnerships, fair access to our own resources, and an end to the presumption that African political choices must remain subordinate to European strategic comfort.

History is not a ledger that can be closed by selective memory.

Examine it without exception. Then answer honestly: if the violence that established your power did not trouble you sufficiently to end it, why should the loss of that power now disturb you?

The future of Africa will be written by Africans. The instruments of the past must not dictate the terms of that future.

The outrage that arrives late

There is no moral contradiction in grieving for people harmed in France. Their lives matter.

The contradiction begins when European suffering is treated as a civilizational emergency while African suffering is treated as background.

To ask whether that double standard is racist is not to accuse every European of personal malice. It is to examine a hierarchy of attention.

Whose death interrupts ordinary politics? Whose dispossession becomes a technical matter? Whose anger demands explanation, and whose power is permitted to explain itself?

If institutional concern becomes active only when suffering reaches Europe, while remaining indifferent to comparable suffering imposed upon Africans, the selectivity is racialised. It deserves scrutiny, not another lecture to Africans about the appropriate temperature of their grief.

But the answer to selective compassion is universal compassion.

Colonial violence does not justify attacks on civilians. People in France are not interchangeable with colonial administrations. African and European lives are not counters to be traded in an argument about whose suffering cancels whose.

The claim is more demanding than revenge: apply the same standard everywhere.

Condemn violence against civilians. Condemn the systems that made violence an instrument of empire. Do not use the first condemnation to escape the second.

Mahakali and the end of immunity

Against the moral darkness associated with Kaliyuga, Mahakali offers an image of truth that will no longer negotiate with arrogance.

Here, the Divine Feminine is not invoked as a decorative reassurance. She is uncompromising discernment: the cutting away of pretence, the exposure of predation, the refusal to let power call itself virtue merely because it possesses a uniform, a bank, or a museum.

The toxic masculine in this argument is not masculinity itself. It is domination that has forgotten how to recognise limits.

It conquers and calls the conquest discovery. It extracts and calls the extraction development. It determines another people’s future and calls the arrangement cooperation.

At its most grotesque, it becomes the civilizational Hannibal Lecter: a cultivated predator explaining, with exquisite manners, why consuming another society is somehow a service to it.

The metaphor concerns the predatory system, not an inherent quality of European people. Its target is the entitlement of empire.

Mahakali does not arrive to flatter that entitlement. She arrives to end its immunity.

Are we witnessing Europe’s last opportunity to atone before Karma takes a more active hand?

That is a moral warning, not a timetable for catastrophe. Karma is not collective guilt inherited by birth, nor a licence to celebrate another person’s injury. In this argument it names the consequences of action, accumulation, and denial.

Institutions that refuse correction can destroy the conditions of their own legitimacy. The wiser course is to undertake repair while reconciliation remains possible.

DTARC’s invitation: the 5Rs

The Dharmic Truth and Reconciliation Council therefore calls for a Truth and Reconciliation initiative between the European Union and the former colonies of European empires.

Not another event at which Europe offers its account of African history and invites Africans to supply the atmosphere. A serious process, jointly governed, with African and other formerly colonised communities participating as equals.

DTARC’s 5Rs provide the structure: Research, Recognise, Remorse, Reparation, Reconciliation.

Research

Open the archives. Establish what happened, where, to whom, and through which institutions.

Research must include conquest, forced labour, massacres, cultural dispossession, commercial extraction, military intervention, and the structures that survived formal independence. It must distinguish established facts from contested estimates and allow testimony from affected communities to shape the questions.

The purpose is not to manufacture a convenient indictment. It is to make evasion more difficult than truth.

Recognise

Recognise the harms established by that research, and the dignity and sovereignty of those subjected to them.

Recognition must include African agency. These were not peoples waiting for Europe to supply them with history. They possessed political worlds that European power disrupted, subordinated, or destroyed.

The phrase “former colony” must cease to function as a discreet claim upon permanent access.

Remorse

Remorse requires more than a sentence carefully drafted to prevent an admission of responsibility.

Governments and institutions must confront what they did and how they benefited. Genuine remorse listens to those harmed and accepts that the injured party does not owe the beneficiary immediate absolution.

It also creates the willingness to change what can still be changed.

Reparation

Reparation makes responsibility practical.

Depending on the evidence and the parties concerned, it may involve the return of cultural property, settlement of substantiated claims, review of extractive agreements, compensation, and reforms that restore genuine economic and political choice.

These are matters for negotiation with those affected, not charitable packages designed entirely by those making the payment.

Reparation is not charity. It is the material work of justice.

Reconciliation

Reconciliation is the relationship made possible by truth and repair.

It must rest on equality, transparent agreements, reciprocal obligations, and respect for self-determination. It cannot mean requiring the formerly colonised to forget so that the former coloniser may feel comfortable.

Nor does it require permanent hostility.

A genuinely post-imperial relationship would allow cooperation without ownership, disagreement without punishment, and friendship without submission.

That is a future worth choosing.

After France

Europe often speaks of law, rights, and reconciliation as the foundations of its modern identity. Those principles must also govern its relationship with the societies its empires subordinated.

African freedom is not an attack on France. The ending of an inherited privilege is not an act of violence against its former beneficiary.

The cage does not become legitimate because the keeper has grown fond of the bird.

Blake’s robin still has its claim upon Heaven. Africa has its claim upon freedom. DTARC’s invitation is to open the ledger and begin the work.

Mahakali has arrived in Europe. After France, where next – London?

Sources and further reading

  1. Al Jazeera, “Debate on ditching CFA begins as Burkina Faso, Mali and Niger debate exiting CFA zone”, 23 February 2024.
  2. Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Berlin Conference”.
  3. Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Algeria: Colonial rule”.
  4. CIPDH, Memorias Situadas, “Martyrs’ Day”, commemorating the 1947 uprising in
  5. Al Jazeera, “Senegal seeks answers 80 years after French colonial massacre of soldiers”, 1 December
  6. Central Bank of West African States, “History of the CFA franc”.
  7. Presidency of the French Republic, “Déclaration du Président de la République sur la mort de Maurice Audin”, 13 September 2018, acknowledging the state-enabled system of detention, torture, and disappearances during the Algerian war.
  8. Bernard Salvaing, Encyclopédie d’histoire numérique de l’Europe, “Forced labor in European colonies”.
  9. International Review of Social History, Cambridge University Press, “Forced Labour and the System of Overburdening in the Interwar Middle Congo: Congolese Populations between Administrative Violence and Local Runaway Schemes (1918-1948)”, 2025.
  10. Bibliothèque nationale de France, “Haiti’s independence The slave as a unit of account (1794-1922)”, published November 2023.
  11. French Ministry for Europe and Foreign Affairs, “Franc Zone”, updated 29 July
  12. French Senate, report on the CFA franc and the Franc Zone, section on reserve deposits, remuneration, and French Treasury funding, 30 September 2020.

Dharmic Truth and Reconciliation Council – DTARC.org

GHF Upcoming Events

Building a Hindu Consensus through Debate & Dialogue

Pt. Satish K. Sharma to Participate in World Hindu Congress 2026

Pt. Satish K. Sharma to Participate in World Hindu Congress 2026

December 18, 2026 - December 20, 2026    
10:00 am - 5:00 pm
Pt. Satish K. Sharma will take part as a delegate at the World Hindu Congress 2026, which will be held in Mumbai from 18 to [...]
Scroll to Top